![]() |
Image retrieved from: http://meetville.com/images/quotes/Quotation-Dorothy- West-identity-Meetville-Quotes-5275.jpg |
The
notion of home is, in itself, an extremely open concept. It—or rather what determines home—is not the same for
everyone. Peter Roberts attributes this to the fact that “home embodies a
psychological factor of attachment”. Home is, indeed, a psychological and
emotional factor. Our place of birth or place of residence doesn’t
categorically decide our notion of home or identity. However, since home is a feeling, they can have some influence
over them, but not categorically decide them. Home is feeling good, secure, happy,
and like you belong. Countless things that are entirely up to the person in
question at a given period of time can determine these feelings. Additionally,
“the human being does not necessarily remain in one place throughout a
lifetime” (Roberts). By “remaining in one place”, Roberts refers to remaining
as an emotional being. We are
constantly changing and evolving; we are not static beings in any sense (physically
and mentally). Since home is determined by our feelings and emotions and these,
in turn, are two continuously changing things, the notion of home is also
ever-changing.
![]() |
Image retrieved from: http://favim.com/orig/201104/25/Favim.com-23850.jpg |
Language as well as the notion of
home is tied to the concept of place. A language is subject to a specific
place—or places. This, in turn, also establishes the sense of the “other”[1].
Roberts describes this factor by stating: “language therefore establishes bonds
between all communities of human beings but at the same time sets up barriers
between communities”. However, when it pertains to identity, language, like the
notion of home and although in lesser degree, can also be subject to
psychological factors. Our language is generally the one of our place of birth or
residence. Nonetheless, our language can also be determined based on a
psychological attachment to a language that has developed from certain
emotional reasons. For example, you may have been born and resided all your
life in the United States where English is the spoken language, but your family
is of Puerto Rican origin—a place where Spanish is spoken, and you feel more
attached to Spanish than to English. You have developed a psychological
attachment to Spanish and assume it as your own even if you have grown up in an
English speaking country. Therefore, Spanish is the language that will come to
identify you. Nevertheless, this phenomenon happens in lesser degree since
acquiring languages is trickier than simply developing a notion of what “home”
means to you.
History also has direct impact over
people’s identities. Our place of birth and residency’s history affects the
identity of its people. A country’s history shapes the countries culture as
well as the minds of its population. Every country comes with its own beliefs
that directly influence that country’s historical background. For example,
Antigua is an island in the Caribbean that was colonized by the English during
the Colonial Era. Jamaica Kincaid, a renowned author from Antigua, directs the
following words towards the English:
Do you know why people like me are shy
about being capitalists? Well, it's because we, for as long as we have known
you, were capital, like bales of cotton and sacks of sugar, and you were the
commanding, cruel capitalists, and the memory of this is so strong, the
experience so recent, that we can't quite bring ourselves to embrace this idea
that you think so much of. As for what we were like before we met you, I no
longer care.
Through
Kincaid’s words, we are able to notice how the historical relationship between
England and Antigua influenced her identity. She doesn’t consider herself a
capitalist because of her experience with capitalist people. Being a capitalist
is not something that’s part of her identity because the history of her
birthplace influenced her to perceive capitalism as something bad and, therefore,
affected her political identity. Furthermore, Kincaid also states: “Have I
given you the impression that the Antigua I grew up in revolved almost
completely around England? Well, that was so. I met the world through England,
and if the world wanted to meet me it would have to do so through England”.
Kincaid openly states the degree of influence England’s presence in Antigua had
over her persona. She acknowledges that her country was completely altered by
England, and, because of that, her identity was dependent of that relationship.
Moreover,
behavior is the thing that influences a person’s identity the most. Roberts
defines the concept to encompass “a wide array including supernatural
practices, entertainment, sports and games, and educational practices”. He
judges it as merely a “category in judgments of identity” (Roberts). However,
behavior is the one thing that
encompasses it all. It can even be
stated that behavior can very well be a synonym of identity. Behavior is
defined by our sense of home, our language, our beliefs, and all the countless
things that determine our identity because it is our identity. More specifically, behavior is the expression of identity. Identity is the
abstract and fleeting concept of the thing itself: who you are. Meanwhile,
behavior is the thing by which the abstract (identity) turns into something
concrete.
![]() | |
Image retrieved from:
|
Identity is a wide, abstract, and fleeting
concept that expresses itself through behavior. Many things determine our
identity; our notion of home, language, historical influences, and behavior are
only a few. The notion of home is not a constant concept that isn’t
categorically determined by birthplace or residence because it’s based on
feelings of security, belonging, and happiness. Therefore it is a concept that
can change multiple times throughout a person’s life. A person’s language is
tied, but not limited to the concept of place. Not only are languages
determined based on the geographical area where they are spoken, but also by
psychological attachments. Moreover, a countries history affects the identity
of its people since it directly affects the country’s culture and beliefs. Behavior
is, however, the most important component of a person’s identity because it is
its expression. A person’s identity—an abstract concept—manifests itself into a
concrete thing through behavior. Many of the things that determine our identity
are psychological factors because identity is not determined by cold hard
facts, but rather individually, by the person in question—a person that can and is subject to all kinds of bias. However, that is precisely the
beauty of identity: like a fingerprint, there are no two alike.
Works Cited
Kincaid,
Jamaica. A Small Place. 1989.
Márquez, Gabriel
García. Quotes About Identity. 2015.
Goodreads, Inc. 2015 February 2015
<http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/tag/identity>.
Roberts,
Peter. The Roots of Caribbean Identity:
Language, Race, and Ecology. New York: Cambridge U.P., 2008. 1-5.
[1]
“Other”: Word that comes from the term “othering”; when it’s identified that
there is a difference between two people and a barrier is created product of
the lack of sameness.
Huh. "Identity is a wide, abstract, fleeting concept that expresses itself through behavior." I'd never thought about relating identity to behavior. That's very interesting. But I don't think behavior is always an accurate representation of our identities. Most of the time, yes. However, depending on where you are or who you are with, sometimes your behavior changes (or adapts). I'm not sure if that makes sense, but for example think about peer pressure: sometimes we are pressured into behaving in certain ways that don't align with our identities... Although these situations are usually the exception to the rule.
ReplyDeleteLove that Garcias Marquez quote, life gives you an opportunity to remake you'er self. You can make a better stronger version of you'er self every time life calls upon it. That finger print analogy keeps getting better. I would love to see a post in wich you merged the both concepts you have used it in. Great as always.
ReplyDeleteSabrina, I believe you are right when you say that most of the time people change their behavior depending on certain things like the people that surround them. However, I believe that precisely the act of changing you're behavior depending on certain things IS in itself a characteristic of your identity.
ReplyDeleteJorge, that's the beauty of life. We get to be better based on the experiences it throws at us; that's why I've always strongly believed that we are the collection of our experiences. Thank you! I hadn't thought of combining the two! I'll take you up on the suggestion!